Background: We aimed to investigate the extent of the agreement on practices around brain death and postmortem organ donation. Methods: Investigators from 67 Collaborative European NeuroTrauma Effectiveness Research in Traumatic Brain Injury (CENTER-TBI) study centers completed several questionnaires (response rate: 99%). Results: Regarding practices around brain death, we found agreement on the clinical evaluation (prerequisites and neurological assessment) for brain death determination (BDD) in 100% of the centers. However, ancillary tests were required for BDD in 64% of the centers. BDD for nondonor patients was deemed mandatory in 18% of the centers before withdrawing life-sustaining measures (LSM). Also, practices around postmortem organ donation varied. Organ donation after circulatory arrest was forbidden in 45% of the centers. When withdrawal of LSM was contemplated, in 67% of centers the patients with a ventricular drain in situ had this removed, either sometimes or all of the time. Conclusions: This study showed both agreement and some regional differences regarding practices around brain death and postmortem organ donation. We hope our results help quantify and understand potential differences, and provide impetus for current dialogs toward further harmonization of practices around brain death and postmortem organ donation.

Brain death and postmortem organ donation: Report of a questionnaire from the CENTER-TBI study

Stocchetti N.;Agnoletti V.;Belli A.;Nelson D.;
2018

Abstract

Background: We aimed to investigate the extent of the agreement on practices around brain death and postmortem organ donation. Methods: Investigators from 67 Collaborative European NeuroTrauma Effectiveness Research in Traumatic Brain Injury (CENTER-TBI) study centers completed several questionnaires (response rate: 99%). Results: Regarding practices around brain death, we found agreement on the clinical evaluation (prerequisites and neurological assessment) for brain death determination (BDD) in 100% of the centers. However, ancillary tests were required for BDD in 64% of the centers. BDD for nondonor patients was deemed mandatory in 18% of the centers before withdrawing life-sustaining measures (LSM). Also, practices around postmortem organ donation varied. Organ donation after circulatory arrest was forbidden in 45% of the centers. When withdrawal of LSM was contemplated, in 67% of centers the patients with a ventricular drain in situ had this removed, either sometimes or all of the time. Conclusions: This study showed both agreement and some regional differences regarding practices around brain death and postmortem organ donation. We hope our results help quantify and understand potential differences, and provide impetus for current dialogs toward further harmonization of practices around brain death and postmortem organ donation.
2018
Van Veen E.; Van Der Jagt M.; Cnossen M.C.; Maas A.I.R.; De Beaufort I.D.; Menon D.K.; Citerio G.; Stocchetti N.; Rietdijk W.J.R.; Van Dijck J.T.J.M.; Kompanje E.J.O.; Ackerlund C.; Adams H.; Agnoletti V.; Allanson J.; Amrein K.; Andaluz N.; Andelic N.; Andreassen L.; Antun A.; Anke A.; Antoni A.; Ardon H.; Audibert G.; Auslands K.; Azouvi P.; Azzolini M.L.; Baciu C.; Badenes R.; Bartels R.; Barzo P.; Bauerfeind U.; Beauvais R.; Beer R.; Francisco J.B.; Bellander B.-M.; Belli A.; Bellier R.; Benali H.; Benard T.; Berardino M.; Beretta L.; Beynon C.; Bilotta F.; Binder H.; Biqiri E.; Blaabjerg M.; Den Boogert H.; Bouzat P.; Bragge P.; Brazinova A.; Brinck V.; Brooker J.; Brorsson C.; Buki A.; Bullinger M.; Calappi E.; Calvi M.R.; Cameron P.; Lozano G.C.; Carbonara M.; Carise E.; Carpenter K.; Castano-Leon A.M.; Causin F.; Chevallard G.; Chieregato A.; Coburn M.; Coles J.; Coles-Kemp L.; Collett J.; Cooper J.D.; Correia M.; Covic A.; Curry N.; Czeiter E.; Czosnyka M.; Dahyot-Fizelier C.; Damas F.; Damas P.; Dawes H.; De Keyser V.; Della Corte F.; Depreitere B.; De Ruiter Godard C.W.; Dilvesi D.; Ding S.; Dippel D.; Dixit A.; Donoghue E.; Dreier J.; Duliere G.-L.; Eapen G.; Engemann H.; Ercole A.; Esser P.; Ezer E.; Fabricius M.; Feigin V.L.; Feng J.; Foks K.; Fossi F.; Francony G.; Freo U.; Frisvold S.; Furmanov A.; Gagliardo P.; Galanaud D.; Gantner D.; Gao G.; Geleijns K.; George P.; Ghuysen A.; Giga L.; Giraud B.; Glocker B.; Golubovic J.; Gomez P.A.; Grossi F.; Gruen R.L.; Gupta D.; Haagsma J.A.; Haitsma I.; Hartings J.A.; Helbok R.; Helseth E.; Hertle D.; Hoedemaekers A.; Hoefer S.; Horton L.; Huijben J.; Hutchinson P.J.; Haberg A.K.; Jacobs B.; Jankowski S.; Jarrett M.; Jelaca B.; Jiang J.-Y.; Jones K.; Kamnitsas K.; Karan M.; Katila A.; Kaukonen M.; Kerforne T.; Kivisaari R.; Kolias A.G.; Kolumban B.; Kolundzija K.; Kondziella D.; Koskinen L.-O.; Kovacs N.; Lagares A.; Lanyon L.; Laureys S.; Lecky F.; Ledig C.; Lefering R.; Legrand V.; Lei J.; Levi L.; Lightfoot R.; Lingsma H.; Loeckx D.; Lozano A.; MacDonald S.; Maegele M.; Majdan M.; Major S.; Manara A.; Manley G.; Didier M.; Martin L.F.; Martino C.; Maruenda A.; Marechal H.; Masala A.; Mattern J.; McFadyen C.; McMahon C.; Melegh B.; Menovsky T.; Morganti-Kossmann C.; Mulazzi D.; Muraleedharan V.; Murray L.; Muhlan H.; Nair N.; Negru A.; Nelson D.; Newcombe V.; Nieboer D.; Noirhomme Q.; Nyiradi J.; Oddo M.; Oldenbeuving A.; Oresic M.; Ortolano F.; Palotie A.; Parizel P.M.; Patruno A.; Payen J.-F.; Perera N.; Perlbarg V.; Persona P.; Peul W.; Piippo-Karjalainen A.; Floury S.P.; Pirinen M.; Ples H.; Poca M.A.; Polinder S.; Pomposo I.; Posti J.; Puybasset L.; Radoi A.; Ragauskas A.; Raj R.; Rambadagalla M.; Real R.; Rehorcikova V.; Rhodes J.; Ripatti S.; Rocka S.; Roe C.; Roise O.; Roks G.; Rosand J.; Rosenfeld J.; Rosenlund C.; Rosenthal G.; Rossaint R.; Rossi S.; Rueckert D.; Rusnak M.; Sacchi M.; Sahakian B.; Sahuquillo J.; Sakowitz O.; Sala F.; Sanchez-Porras R.; Sandor J.; Santos E.; Sasu L.; Savo D.; Schaffer N.; Schipper I.; Schlosser B.; Schmidt S.; Schoechl H.; Schoonman G.; Schou R.F.; Schwendenwein E.; Scholl M.; Sir O.; Skandsen T.; Smakman L.; Smeets D.; Smielewski P.; Sorinola A.; Stamatakis E.; Stanworth S.; Steinbuchel N.; Stevanovic A.; Stevens R.; Stewart W.; Steyerberg E.W.; Sundstrom N.; Synnot A.; Taccone F.S.; Takala R.; Tamas V.; Tanskanen P.; Taylor M.S.; Te Ao B.; Tenovuo O.; Telgmann R.; Teodorani G.; Theadom A.; Thomas M.; Tibboel D.; Tolias C.; Tshibanda J.-F.L.; Trapani T.; Tudora C.M.; Vajkoczy P.; Vallance S.; Valeinis E.; Van Der Steen G.; Van Der Naalt J.; Van Essen T.A.; Van Hecke W.; Van Heugten C.; Van Praag D.; Vyvere T.V.; Van Waesberghe J.; Vanhaudenhuyse A.; Vargiolu A.; Vega E.; Velt K.; Verheyden J.; Vespa P.M.; Vik A.; Vilcinis R.; Vizzino G.; Vleggeert-Lankamp C.; Volovici V.; Voormolen D.; Vulekovic P.; Vamos Z.; Wade D.; Wang K.K.W.; Wang L.; Wessels L.; Wildschut E.; Williams G.; Wilson L.; Winkler M.K.L.; Wolf S.; Ylen P.; Younsi A.; Zaaroor M.; Zhihui Y.; Ziverte A.; Zumbo F.
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
13054_2018_Article_2241.pdf

accesso aperto

Tipo: Versione (PDF) editoriale
Licenza: Licenza per Accesso Aperto. Creative Commons Attribuzione (CCBY)
Dimensione 428.35 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
428.35 kB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri
13054_2018_2241_MOESM1_ESM.pdf

accesso aperto

Tipo: File Supplementare
Licenza: Licenza per Accesso Aperto. Creative Commons Universal – Donazione al Pubblico Dominio (CC0 1.0)
Dimensione 596.25 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
596.25 kB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11585/915896
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus 10
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? 9
social impact