Purpose: To evaluate the in vivo knee laxity in the presence of a partial medial meniscectomy before and after a single-bundle ACL reconstruction with a lateral plasty (SBLP) and to compare it with the knee laxity after a single-bundle ACL reconstruction (SB). Methods: One-hundred and one patients with ACL tear were enrolled in the study and grouped according to the surgical technique and the meniscus treatment: regarding the SBLP technique (n = 55), 31 patients underwent isolated ACL reconstruction (“SBLP Isolated ACL Group”), while 24 patients underwent combined ACL reconstruction and partial medial meniscectomy (“SBLP ACL + MM Group”); regarding the SB technique (n = 46), 33 patients underwent isolated ACL reconstruction (“SB Isolated ACL Group”), while 13 patients underwent combined ACL reconstruction and partial medial meniscectomy (“SB ACL + MM Group”). Anterior–posterior clinical laxity at 30° (AP30) and 90° (AP90) of knee flexion was quantified before and after surgery through a surgical navigation system dedicated to kinematic assessment. Results: In the ACL-deficient status, the antero-posterior laxity was significantly higher in the presence of a combined MM in both the AP30 and the AP90, with no differences between the two surgical techniques. After the ACL reconstruction, both AP30 and AP90 translations decreased significantly (p < 0.0001) compared to the ACL-deficient status. No differences were found for AP30 and AP90 between SBLP Isolated ACL and SBLP + MM groups, while a significantly higher AP90 translation was found for the SB + MM group compared to the SB Isolated ACL group. Moreover, the AP90 translation in the SB ACL + MM group was significantly higher than the one of the other three groups, i.e., SBLP ACL + MM, SB, and SBLP Isolated ACL group. Conclusion: The ACL reconstruction with lateral plasty reduced the AP knee laxity caused by the medial meniscectomy in the context of an ACL surgery. Level of evidence: Level II.
Di Paolo S., Grassi A., Pizza N., Lucidi G.A., Dal Fabbro G., Macchiarola L., et al. (2021). Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with lateral plasty restores anterior–posterior laxity in the case of concurrent partial medial meniscectomy. KNEE SURGERY, SPORTS TRAUMATOLOGY, ARTHROSCOPY, 1, 1-7 [10.1007/s00167-021-06689-3].
Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with lateral plasty restores anterior–posterior laxity in the case of concurrent partial medial meniscectomy
Di Paolo S.;Grassi A.;Pizza N.;Lucidi G. A.;Dal Fabbro G.;Macchiarola L.;Zaffagnini S.
2021
Abstract
Purpose: To evaluate the in vivo knee laxity in the presence of a partial medial meniscectomy before and after a single-bundle ACL reconstruction with a lateral plasty (SBLP) and to compare it with the knee laxity after a single-bundle ACL reconstruction (SB). Methods: One-hundred and one patients with ACL tear were enrolled in the study and grouped according to the surgical technique and the meniscus treatment: regarding the SBLP technique (n = 55), 31 patients underwent isolated ACL reconstruction (“SBLP Isolated ACL Group”), while 24 patients underwent combined ACL reconstruction and partial medial meniscectomy (“SBLP ACL + MM Group”); regarding the SB technique (n = 46), 33 patients underwent isolated ACL reconstruction (“SB Isolated ACL Group”), while 13 patients underwent combined ACL reconstruction and partial medial meniscectomy (“SB ACL + MM Group”). Anterior–posterior clinical laxity at 30° (AP30) and 90° (AP90) of knee flexion was quantified before and after surgery through a surgical navigation system dedicated to kinematic assessment. Results: In the ACL-deficient status, the antero-posterior laxity was significantly higher in the presence of a combined MM in both the AP30 and the AP90, with no differences between the two surgical techniques. After the ACL reconstruction, both AP30 and AP90 translations decreased significantly (p < 0.0001) compared to the ACL-deficient status. No differences were found for AP30 and AP90 between SBLP Isolated ACL and SBLP + MM groups, while a significantly higher AP90 translation was found for the SB + MM group compared to the SB Isolated ACL group. Moreover, the AP90 translation in the SB ACL + MM group was significantly higher than the one of the other three groups, i.e., SBLP ACL + MM, SB, and SBLP Isolated ACL group. Conclusion: The ACL reconstruction with lateral plasty reduced the AP knee laxity caused by the medial meniscectomy in the context of an ACL surgery. Level of evidence: Level II.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
