The peer-review crisis is posing a risk to the scholarly peer-reviewed journal system. Journals have to ask many potential peer reviewers to obtain a minimum acceptable number of peers accepting reviewing a manuscript. Several solutions have been suggested to overcome this shortage. From reimbursing for the job, to eliminating pre-publication reviews, one cannot predict which is more dangerous for the future of scholarly publishing. And, why not acknowledging their contribution to the final version of the article published? PubMed created two categories of contributors: authors [AU] and collaborators [IR]. Why not a third category for the peer-reviewer?.

Scholarly publishing depends on peer reviewers / Fernandez-Llimos F.; Berti A.D.; Yeung D.; Yusuff K.B.; El Zowalaty M.E.; Adane E.D.; Al-Aqeel S.; Al-Jumaili A.A.; Alili-Idrizi E.; Andelkovic M.; Aranha A.; Arief M.; Arkaravichien W.; Armoiry X.; Attarabeen O.F.; Ayoub N.; Bajorek B.V.; Beninger P.; Billups S.J.; Bowen J.F.; Bouwmeester C.; Campbell P.; Chan V.; Connor S.E.; Danziger L.H.; Dawood O.T.; Dunnenberger M.; Elrouby S.; Fakih S.; Abu Farha R.K.; Figueiredo I.V.; Foroutan N.; Forsythe L.E.; Frail C.K.; Friesner D.; Funk K.; Gaither C.; Gallimore C.E.; Gan V.; Garcia B.H.; Gaskins J.L.; Gastelurrutia M.A.; Gatwood J.; Genord C.K.; Gilliam E.; Goodbar N.H.; Gossell-Williams M.; Grundy Q.; Guenette L.; Hadi M.A.; Hallit S.; Hammond D.A.; Hawasli R.S.; Herdeiro M.T.; Hermansyah A.; Hincapie A.L.; Hoehns J.D.; Hossain L.N.; Hudspeth B.; Ibrahim M.I.B.M.; Islahudin F.; Jacobsen R.; Jones M.; Kalvemark Sporrong S.; Kantelhardt P.; Katangwe T.; Katoue M.G.; King S.R.; Kinnear M.; Kouladjian O'Donnell L.; Kovacevic S.V.; Krass I.; Kraus S.K.; Lakic D.; Larson D.; LeMay K.; Loh B.C.; Lowres N.; Luetsch K.; Lunghi C.; Lyra D.P.; Ma C.S.; MacDonald E.A.; Mancuso M.A.; Mazhar F.; McCarthy L.; McComb M.; McFarland M.S.; Mehralian G.; Merks P.; Modun D.; Mohammed M.A.; Motulsky A.; Mukattash T.L.; Nabhani-Gebara S.; Najafi S.; Ni W.; Nitadpakorn S.; Ogbo P.U.; Palaian S.; Patel R.J.; Payne M.H.; Peaslee A.K.; Pereira L.R.; Perry T.D.; Phan Y.; Plage S.; Prybylski J.P.; Quffa L.H.; Raka L.; Ramos-Esquivel A.; Ramsbottom H.; Rayes I.K.; Rodriguez J.V.; Rosenthal M.; Sadowski C.A.; Sage A.; Salgado T.M.; Saw P.S.; Schafer K.M.; Schutte T.; Shafie A.A.; Shah R.M.; Sharma A.; Shehnaz S.I.; Shiyanbola O.O.; Siitonen P.; Skinner I.; Snyder M.E.; Stewart D.; Strang A.; Stranges P.M.; Sultana K.; Surbhi S.; Suzen H.S.; Swieczkowski D.; Tasaka C.L.; Taylor A.M.; Theberge C.R.; Travlos D.V.; Turner J.R.; Vandenberk B.; Wettergreen S.A.; White C.M.; Wietholter J.P.; Wirth F.; Young A.; Zembles T.. - In: PHARMACY PRACTICE. - ISSN 1886-3655. - ELETTRONICO. - 16:1(2018), pp. 1-4. [10.18549/PharmPract.2018.01.1236]

Scholarly publishing depends on peer reviewers

Lunghi C.;
2018

Abstract

The peer-review crisis is posing a risk to the scholarly peer-reviewed journal system. Journals have to ask many potential peer reviewers to obtain a minimum acceptable number of peers accepting reviewing a manuscript. Several solutions have been suggested to overcome this shortage. From reimbursing for the job, to eliminating pre-publication reviews, one cannot predict which is more dangerous for the future of scholarly publishing. And, why not acknowledging their contribution to the final version of the article published? PubMed created two categories of contributors: authors [AU] and collaborators [IR]. Why not a third category for the peer-reviewer?.
2018
Scholarly publishing depends on peer reviewers / Fernandez-Llimos F.; Berti A.D.; Yeung D.; Yusuff K.B.; El Zowalaty M.E.; Adane E.D.; Al-Aqeel S.; Al-Jumaili A.A.; Alili-Idrizi E.; Andelkovic M.; Aranha A.; Arief M.; Arkaravichien W.; Armoiry X.; Attarabeen O.F.; Ayoub N.; Bajorek B.V.; Beninger P.; Billups S.J.; Bowen J.F.; Bouwmeester C.; Campbell P.; Chan V.; Connor S.E.; Danziger L.H.; Dawood O.T.; Dunnenberger M.; Elrouby S.; Fakih S.; Abu Farha R.K.; Figueiredo I.V.; Foroutan N.; Forsythe L.E.; Frail C.K.; Friesner D.; Funk K.; Gaither C.; Gallimore C.E.; Gan V.; Garcia B.H.; Gaskins J.L.; Gastelurrutia M.A.; Gatwood J.; Genord C.K.; Gilliam E.; Goodbar N.H.; Gossell-Williams M.; Grundy Q.; Guenette L.; Hadi M.A.; Hallit S.; Hammond D.A.; Hawasli R.S.; Herdeiro M.T.; Hermansyah A.; Hincapie A.L.; Hoehns J.D.; Hossain L.N.; Hudspeth B.; Ibrahim M.I.B.M.; Islahudin F.; Jacobsen R.; Jones M.; Kalvemark Sporrong S.; Kantelhardt P.; Katangwe T.; Katoue M.G.; King S.R.; Kinnear M.; Kouladjian O'Donnell L.; Kovacevic S.V.; Krass I.; Kraus S.K.; Lakic D.; Larson D.; LeMay K.; Loh B.C.; Lowres N.; Luetsch K.; Lunghi C.; Lyra D.P.; Ma C.S.; MacDonald E.A.; Mancuso M.A.; Mazhar F.; McCarthy L.; McComb M.; McFarland M.S.; Mehralian G.; Merks P.; Modun D.; Mohammed M.A.; Motulsky A.; Mukattash T.L.; Nabhani-Gebara S.; Najafi S.; Ni W.; Nitadpakorn S.; Ogbo P.U.; Palaian S.; Patel R.J.; Payne M.H.; Peaslee A.K.; Pereira L.R.; Perry T.D.; Phan Y.; Plage S.; Prybylski J.P.; Quffa L.H.; Raka L.; Ramos-Esquivel A.; Ramsbottom H.; Rayes I.K.; Rodriguez J.V.; Rosenthal M.; Sadowski C.A.; Sage A.; Salgado T.M.; Saw P.S.; Schafer K.M.; Schutte T.; Shafie A.A.; Shah R.M.; Sharma A.; Shehnaz S.I.; Shiyanbola O.O.; Siitonen P.; Skinner I.; Snyder M.E.; Stewart D.; Strang A.; Stranges P.M.; Sultana K.; Surbhi S.; Suzen H.S.; Swieczkowski D.; Tasaka C.L.; Taylor A.M.; Theberge C.R.; Travlos D.V.; Turner J.R.; Vandenberk B.; Wettergreen S.A.; White C.M.; Wietholter J.P.; Wirth F.; Young A.; Zembles T.. - In: PHARMACY PRACTICE. - ISSN 1886-3655. - ELETTRONICO. - 16:1(2018), pp. 1-4. [10.18549/PharmPract.2018.01.1236]
Fernandez-Llimos F.; Berti A.D.; Yeung D.; Yusuff K.B.; El Zowalaty M.E.; Adane E.D.; Al-Aqeel S.; Al-Jumaili A.A.; Alili-Idrizi E.; Andelkovic M.; Aranha A.; Arief M.; Arkaravichien W.; Armoiry X.; Attarabeen O.F.; Ayoub N.; Bajorek B.V.; Beninger P.; Billups S.J.; Bowen J.F.; Bouwmeester C.; Campbell P.; Chan V.; Connor S.E.; Danziger L.H.; Dawood O.T.; Dunnenberger M.; Elrouby S.; Fakih S.; Abu Farha R.K.; Figueiredo I.V.; Foroutan N.; Forsythe L.E.; Frail C.K.; Friesner D.; Funk K.; Gaither C.; Gallimore C.E.; Gan V.; Garcia B.H.; Gaskins J.L.; Gastelurrutia M.A.; Gatwood J.; Genord C.K.; Gilliam E.; Goodbar N.H.; Gossell-Williams M.; Grundy Q.; Guenette L.; Hadi M.A.; Hallit S.; Hammond D.A.; Hawasli R.S.; Herdeiro M.T.; Hermansyah A.; Hincapie A.L.; Hoehns J.D.; Hossain L.N.; Hudspeth B.; Ibrahim M.I.B.M.; Islahudin F.; Jacobsen R.; Jones M.; Kalvemark Sporrong S.; Kantelhardt P.; Katangwe T.; Katoue M.G.; King S.R.; Kinnear M.; Kouladjian O'Donnell L.; Kovacevic S.V.; Krass I.; Kraus S.K.; Lakic D.; Larson D.; LeMay K.; Loh B.C.; Lowres N.; Luetsch K.; Lunghi C.; Lyra D.P.; Ma C.S.; MacDonald E.A.; Mancuso M.A.; Mazhar F.; McCarthy L.; McComb M.; McFarland M.S.; Mehralian G.; Merks P.; Modun D.; Mohammed M.A.; Motulsky A.; Mukattash T.L.; Nabhani-Gebara S.; Najafi S.; Ni W.; Nitadpakorn S.; Ogbo P.U.; Palaian S.; Patel R.J.; Payne M.H.; Peaslee A.K.; Pereira L.R.; Perry T.D.; Phan Y.; Plage S.; Prybylski J.P.; Quffa L.H.; Raka L.; Ramos-Esquivel A.; Ramsbottom H.; Rayes I.K.; Rodriguez J.V.; Rosenthal M.; Sadowski C.A.; Sage A.; Salgado T.M.; Saw P.S.; Schafer K.M.; Schutte T.; Shafie A.A.; Shah R.M.; Sharma A.; Shehnaz S.I.; Shiyanbola O.O.; Siitonen P.; Skinner I.; Snyder M.E.; Stewart D.; Strang A.; Stranges P.M.; Sultana K.; Surbhi S.; Suzen H.S.; Swieczkowski D.; Tasaka C.L.; Taylor A.M.; Theberge C.R.; Travlos D.V.; Turner J.R.; Vandenberk B.; Wettergreen S.A.; White C.M.; Wietholter J.P.; Wirth F.; Young A.; Zembles T.
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
f-llimos,+PP-1236.pdf

accesso aperto

Tipo: Versione (PDF) editoriale
Licenza: Licenza per Accesso Aperto. Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate (CCBYNCND)
Dimensione 346.75 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
346.75 kB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11585/845185
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus 6
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? 6
social impact