Different tracheotomy tube diameters influence diaphragmatic effort and indices of weanability in difficult to wean patients

OBJECTIVE: To determine the effects of different tracheotomy tube sizes on diaphragm effort and weanability indices. METHODS: Ten tracheotomized and difficult to wean subjects were randomized to 2 T-piece trials, with different tracheotomy tube diameters: inner diameters 8 mm and 6.5 mm. Diaphragm pressure-time product per min. (PTP(di/min)), lung compliance and resistance (C(L) and R(L)), breathing pattern, tension-time index of the diaphragm (TT(di)), and the ratio of breathing frequency to tidal volume (f/V(T)) were recorded. In an in vitro model, the flow-pressure relationship was measured using the 2 tracheotomy tubes and 2 endotracheal tubes of the same diameter. RESULTS: The use of a smaller diameter resulted in an increase of PTP(di) (337.63 ± 194.35 cm H(2)O · s/min vs 263.28 ± 156.23 cm H(2)O · s/min for 6.5 mm and 8 mm, respectively, P = .004) and R(L) (16.74 ± 8.10 cm H(2)O · s/min vs 11.72 ± 7.88 cm H(2)O · s/min, respectively, P = .008). Both weanability indices were also significantly higher using the smaller tube: f/V(T) 93.32 ± 20.91 vs 77.06 ± 19.26 for 6.5 mm and 8 mm, respectively, P < .02; TT(di) 0.09 ± 0.052 vs 0.08 ± 0.04, respectively, P < .02. In vitro measurements confirmed that the resistances were higher with the smaller diameter and similar between the tracheotomy tubes and the endotracheal tubes of the same diameters. CONCLUSIONS: In tracheotomized difficult to wean subjects the decrease of the tracheotomy tube size was associated with an increased PTP(di), f/V(T), and TT(di), that were otherwise normal, using a higher diameter. The in vitro study showed that the resistances increased similarly for tracheotomy tube and endotracheal tube, decreasing the diameter and increasing the flows.