Efficacy and Clinical Outcome of Philadelphia (Ph) Positive Acute Lymphoblastic Leukemia (ALL) Patients Treated with Second Generation Tyrosine Kinase Inhibitors (TKIs): The Bologna Experience

Background. The prognosis of Ph+ adult ALL patients treated with standard therapies, including multi-agent chemotherapy, Imatinib, and allogeneic stem cell transplantation, is still dismal, due to a high risk of relapse. Dasatinib and Nilotinb are second generation TKIs developed to overcome the problem of resistance to Imatinib in relapsed Ph+ leukemias. Design and Methods. We retrospectively evaluated the single center experience on therapy efficacy of Dasatinib, Nilotinib, and experimental third generation TKIs, administered as second or subsequent line of therapy on 25 relapsed Ph+ adult ALL patients. All patients were previously treated with Imatinib. The median age at time of diagnosis was 50 years (range 18-74), 17 patients were male and 8 female. Ten patients presented a BCR-ABL P190 fusion protein and corresponding fusion transcript, the remaining a BCR-ABL P210. Nineteen patients received Dasatinib, 2 patients Nilotinib and the remaining 4 patients were treated with third generation TKIs. Fourteen patients (56%) were in first relapse, and 7 (28%), 3 (12%) and 1 (4%) were in second, third and fourth relapse, respectively. A mutational analysis was performed in all the patients before TKIs (9 wild type, 16 mutated, including T315I) and at the time of subsequent relapse; gene expression profiling, SNPArray (6.0 Affymetrix chip), and Ikaros deletions were also analyzed. Results. 13 out of 25 patients (52%) obtained a haematological response (HR) (11 patients treated with Dasatinib, 1 patient with Nilotinib and 1 patient with a third generation experimental TKI). 10 patients obtained also a cytogenetic response (CyR) and 6 patients a molecular response (MolR). With a median follow up of 10.8 months (range 2-29 months), median duration of HR, CyR and MolR were 117 days (range 14-385 days); progression free survival were 162 days with Dasatinib and 91 days with Nilotinib. Overall survival was 25.8 months. Interestingly, in 6 out of 9 wild-type patients, treated with Dasatinib, the mutational analysis showed the emergence of T315I or F317I mutation at the time of relapse. Conclusion. Second and third generation TKIs represent a valid approach in relapsed Ph+ adult ALL patients; the subsequent relapse is often associated to the emergence of mutation, conferring resistance to TKIs. Since TKIs are different and have different efficacy, pharmacokinetic, pharmacodynamic and toxicity profiles, and since are all effective, an alternative experimental option for the treatment of Ph+ ALL could be a combination or a rotation of two or more than two TKIs. Moreover, the addition of new promising targeted molecules, such as Aurora kinase or T315I inhibitors may contribute to overcome the problem of resistance to TKIs.