The article examines the role of fraternity in Rawls’ A Theory of Justice, arguing that it functions as a foundational element of a conception of solidarity within liberal democratic societies. Fraternity plays a key normative role, especially in connection with the Difference Principle, by presenting justice not only as distributive fairness but also as a relation of reciprocal concern among free and equal citizens. First, the article reconstructs a Rawlsian account of solidarity through an analysis of fraternity, civic friendship, and elements of moral psychology, showing how a shared sense of justice emerges from participation in cooperative social practices. The article later explores the Aristotelian roots of this view, focusing on the concepts of philia and homonoia within the polis. By comparing Rawls’ idea of fraternity with Aristotle’s civic friendship, the article argues that solidarity can be understood as a form of ‘friendly justice’ that strengthens democratic legitimacy.
Irrera, E. (2026). The Aristotelian Roots of Rawls' Fraternity Principle in A Theory of Justice: a Form of Solidarity?. POLIS, 43(3), 426-449 [10.1163/20512996-12340511].
The Aristotelian Roots of Rawls' Fraternity Principle in A Theory of Justice: a Form of Solidarity?
Elena Irrera
2026
Abstract
The article examines the role of fraternity in Rawls’ A Theory of Justice, arguing that it functions as a foundational element of a conception of solidarity within liberal democratic societies. Fraternity plays a key normative role, especially in connection with the Difference Principle, by presenting justice not only as distributive fairness but also as a relation of reciprocal concern among free and equal citizens. First, the article reconstructs a Rawlsian account of solidarity through an analysis of fraternity, civic friendship, and elements of moral psychology, showing how a shared sense of justice emerges from participation in cooperative social practices. The article later explores the Aristotelian roots of this view, focusing on the concepts of philia and homonoia within the polis. By comparing Rawls’ idea of fraternity with Aristotle’s civic friendship, the article argues that solidarity can be understood as a form of ‘friendly justice’ that strengthens democratic legitimacy.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.



