Agricultural sustainability transitions depend not only on technological and institutional innovation but also on communication between grassroots initiatives and policy frameworks. This study examines how European permaculture, conceptualised as a transformative radical niche, constructs its discourse and relates to the European Common Agricultural Policy (CAP). We analyse 496 English-language blog posts published between 2018 and mid-2025 by European permaculture organisations and practitioners using text mining, sentiment analysis, and semiotic interpretation. Permaculture discourse is coherent and affectively rich, centring on regeneration, community, biodiversity, and ecological care, with trust, joy, and anticipation emerging as the predominant emotions. Although it partially converges with CAP discourse around ecological practices and sustainability goals, deeper misalignments emerge in narrative logics, value systems, and interpretations of agricultural transformation. These findings indicate that communicative and narrative disconnects may constrain niche empowerment alongside institutional and structural barriers. Building on these findings, the study proposes an exploratory bridge vocabulary intended to facilitate communication between grassroots initiatives and policy actors, although its practical effectiveness remains to be empirically tested. By integrating computational text analysis and semiotic interpretation, the study advances methodological approaches to analysing discursive alignment in niche–regime interactions.
Meriani, A., D'Attoma, I. (2026). Narratives of sustainable transition: A semiotic and statistical text mining analysis of European permaculture as a transformative niche within the CAP regime. JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION, 580, 1-20 [10.1016/j.jclepro.2026.149663].
Narratives of sustainable transition: A semiotic and statistical text mining analysis of European permaculture as a transformative niche within the CAP regime
Alessandra Meriani;Ida D'attoma
2026
Abstract
Agricultural sustainability transitions depend not only on technological and institutional innovation but also on communication between grassroots initiatives and policy frameworks. This study examines how European permaculture, conceptualised as a transformative radical niche, constructs its discourse and relates to the European Common Agricultural Policy (CAP). We analyse 496 English-language blog posts published between 2018 and mid-2025 by European permaculture organisations and practitioners using text mining, sentiment analysis, and semiotic interpretation. Permaculture discourse is coherent and affectively rich, centring on regeneration, community, biodiversity, and ecological care, with trust, joy, and anticipation emerging as the predominant emotions. Although it partially converges with CAP discourse around ecological practices and sustainability goals, deeper misalignments emerge in narrative logics, value systems, and interpretations of agricultural transformation. These findings indicate that communicative and narrative disconnects may constrain niche empowerment alongside institutional and structural barriers. Building on these findings, the study proposes an exploratory bridge vocabulary intended to facilitate communication between grassroots initiatives and policy actors, although its practical effectiveness remains to be empirically tested. By integrating computational text analysis and semiotic interpretation, the study advances methodological approaches to analysing discursive alignment in niche–regime interactions.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.



