Hallux Sesamoid Nonunion: A Comprehensive Systematic Review of Current Evidence

Introduction: The optimal management of hallux sesamoid fracture nonunions remains a subject of ongoing debate, particularly in the context of personalized medicine. This systematic review aimed to synthesize current evidence regarding surgical strategies for this rare but disabling condition. Methods: A comprehensive literature search was conducted in accordance with the PRISMA guidelines. Results: Six studies met the inclusion criteria, encompassing a total of 80 patients. Surgical techniques varied and included open and arthroscopic sesamoidectomy, autologous bone grafting (alone or combined with screw fixation), and percutaneous screw fixation. When reported, outcomes were generally favorable, with union rates ranging from 90.5% to 100% and with consistent postoperative improvements in clinical function. Complication and reoperation rates were both 6.5%. The most frequent reoperation was sesamoidectomy for persistent pain or nonunion, followed by hardware removal. Conclusions: Despite the limited and low-quality evidence, available data suggest that individualized surgical planning can lead to favorable outcomes with low complication rates. Sesamoidectomy remains the most reliable salvage procedure in refractory cases. These findings support a personalized, stepwise approach to treatment—prioritizing sesamoid preservation, when feasible, while reserving excision for symptomatic nonunions. Further studies are needed to validate tailored algorithms and refine patient-specific decision-making in this challenging clinical scenario.