Chlorinated aliphatic hydrocarbons (CAHs) are widespread groundwater contaminants. Aerobic cometabolism, that requires the supply of a suitable growth substrate, represents an interesting option for the remediation of CAH-contaminated aquifers, thanks to its capability to lead to the complete mineralization of a very wide range of CAHs. The aim of this study was to develop and validate a procedure relative to the lab-scale tests required to obtain the essential information for the design of a process of CAH aerobic cometabolism in a packed bed reactor (PBR). To validate the procedure, the latter was applied to the development of a PBR process for the on-site aerobic cometabolism of an aquifer contaminated by trichloroethylene (TCE) and 1,1,2,2-tetrachloroethane (TeCA). The specific goals of this study, corresponding to the main steps of the above-mentioned procedure, were: (i) to select the best growth substrate for the aerobic cometabolic process, and to develop and characterize an effective CAH-degrading microbial consortium, obtained from the site’s indigenous biomass by exposition to the selected substrate; (ii) to select the best carrier for the PBR process, and to evaluate the effect of bacterial adhesion on the developed suspended-cell consortium; and (iii) to identify and test suitable chemical-physical remediation alternatives in the case of presence of CAHs poorly biodegradable through AC. With regard to the growth substrate selection, the comparison of the CAH degradation performances obtained with 5 candidate substrates (methane, propane, butane, pentane and phenol) led to the selection of butane and to the development from the site’s indigenous biomass of a suspended-cell consortium capable to degrade TCE (TCE first-order constant (k1,TCE) = 96 L gprotein-1 d-1 at 30 °C and 4.3 L gprotein-1 d-1 at 15 °C) with a 90% mineralization of the organic Cl. Based on PCR-DGGE analysis of the 16S rRNA genes followed by band excision and sequencing, the microbial consortium enriched was mainly composed of Bacteroidetes and Alpha- and Beta-Proteobacteria that were distantly related to known CAH-cometabolizing bacteria. With regard to the selection of the best-performing biofilm carrier, a preliminary screening based on the previous experience of the research group led to the pre-selection of four candidate biofilm carriers (porous materials specifically designed for biofilm processes): Biomax, Biomech, Biopearl and Cerambios. The choice of the best-performing carrier was made by means of a 2-level procedure. The 1st level consisted of batch tests, operated both at 30 and 15 °C, whereas the 2nd level consisted of continuous-flow tests, operated at 30 °C. The 30 °C continuous-flow tests were conducted in four 1 L packed columns, connected to a feeding system designed so as to attain a pulsed feed of both oxygen and the selected growth substrate (butane). The four columns were operated in continuous mode for about 100 days. The results of the attached-cell tests were compared on the basis of the TCE normalized degradation rate ( and ) and of the attached cell concentration attained, at the two temperatures, at the end of the biofilm development process. On the basis of both the batch and the continuous-flow tests, Biomax resulted the best-performing biofilm carrier. Biomass immobilization on the carrier changed remarkably the structure of the microbial consortium. The effect on k1,TCE of biomass attachment depended on temperature: at 15 °C the attached consortium performed slightly better than the suspended one, whereas at 30 °C an opposite trend was noticed. On the basis of a 1st-order simulation, a 99.9% TCE conversion can be attained, at the site’s temperature, with a 9-hour HRT. Lastly, the low TeCA degradation rate by the developed consortium suggested the introduction of a chemical pre-treatment based on the TeCA to TCE conversion via -elimination, a very fast reaction at alkaline pH. On the basis of the overall results, the procedure for the development of a PBR AC process appears to be correctly designed and generally applicable to CAH contaminated sites.
Dario Frascari, Giacomo Bucchi, Francesco Doria, Antonella Rosato, Nasrin Tavanaie, Roberta Ciavarelli, et al. (2013). DEVELOPMENT OF A BIOFILM ON-SITE PROCESS FOR THE AEROBIC COMETABOLIC BIOREMEDIATION OF A GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATED BY TRICHLOROETHYLENE AND 1,1,2,2-TETRACHLOROETHANE.
DEVELOPMENT OF A BIOFILM ON-SITE PROCESS FOR THE AEROBIC COMETABOLIC BIOREMEDIATION OF A GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATED BY TRICHLOROETHYLENE AND 1,1,2,2-TETRACHLOROETHANE
FRASCARI, DARIO;BUCCHI, GIACOMO;ROSATO, ANTONELLA;TAVANAIE, NASRIN;CIAVARELLI, ROBERTA;PINELLI, DAVIDE;FRARACCIO, SERENA;ZANAROLI, GIULIO;FAVA, FABIO
2013
Abstract
Chlorinated aliphatic hydrocarbons (CAHs) are widespread groundwater contaminants. Aerobic cometabolism, that requires the supply of a suitable growth substrate, represents an interesting option for the remediation of CAH-contaminated aquifers, thanks to its capability to lead to the complete mineralization of a very wide range of CAHs. The aim of this study was to develop and validate a procedure relative to the lab-scale tests required to obtain the essential information for the design of a process of CAH aerobic cometabolism in a packed bed reactor (PBR). To validate the procedure, the latter was applied to the development of a PBR process for the on-site aerobic cometabolism of an aquifer contaminated by trichloroethylene (TCE) and 1,1,2,2-tetrachloroethane (TeCA). The specific goals of this study, corresponding to the main steps of the above-mentioned procedure, were: (i) to select the best growth substrate for the aerobic cometabolic process, and to develop and characterize an effective CAH-degrading microbial consortium, obtained from the site’s indigenous biomass by exposition to the selected substrate; (ii) to select the best carrier for the PBR process, and to evaluate the effect of bacterial adhesion on the developed suspended-cell consortium; and (iii) to identify and test suitable chemical-physical remediation alternatives in the case of presence of CAHs poorly biodegradable through AC. With regard to the growth substrate selection, the comparison of the CAH degradation performances obtained with 5 candidate substrates (methane, propane, butane, pentane and phenol) led to the selection of butane and to the development from the site’s indigenous biomass of a suspended-cell consortium capable to degrade TCE (TCE first-order constant (k1,TCE) = 96 L gprotein-1 d-1 at 30 °C and 4.3 L gprotein-1 d-1 at 15 °C) with a 90% mineralization of the organic Cl. Based on PCR-DGGE analysis of the 16S rRNA genes followed by band excision and sequencing, the microbial consortium enriched was mainly composed of Bacteroidetes and Alpha- and Beta-Proteobacteria that were distantly related to known CAH-cometabolizing bacteria. With regard to the selection of the best-performing biofilm carrier, a preliminary screening based on the previous experience of the research group led to the pre-selection of four candidate biofilm carriers (porous materials specifically designed for biofilm processes): Biomax, Biomech, Biopearl and Cerambios. The choice of the best-performing carrier was made by means of a 2-level procedure. The 1st level consisted of batch tests, operated both at 30 and 15 °C, whereas the 2nd level consisted of continuous-flow tests, operated at 30 °C. The 30 °C continuous-flow tests were conducted in four 1 L packed columns, connected to a feeding system designed so as to attain a pulsed feed of both oxygen and the selected growth substrate (butane). The four columns were operated in continuous mode for about 100 days. The results of the attached-cell tests were compared on the basis of the TCE normalized degradation rate ( and ) and of the attached cell concentration attained, at the two temperatures, at the end of the biofilm development process. On the basis of both the batch and the continuous-flow tests, Biomax resulted the best-performing biofilm carrier. Biomass immobilization on the carrier changed remarkably the structure of the microbial consortium. The effect on k1,TCE of biomass attachment depended on temperature: at 15 °C the attached consortium performed slightly better than the suspended one, whereas at 30 °C an opposite trend was noticed. On the basis of a 1st-order simulation, a 99.9% TCE conversion can be attained, at the site’s temperature, with a 9-hour HRT. Lastly, the low TeCA degradation rate by the developed consortium suggested the introduction of a chemical pre-treatment based on the TeCA to TCE conversion via -elimination, a very fast reaction at alkaline pH. On the basis of the overall results, the procedure for the development of a PBR AC process appears to be correctly designed and generally applicable to CAH contaminated sites.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.