The aim of this chapter is to investigate the current state of liberal democracy in Italy. The theoretical framework for this analysis has been provided by recent studies (Coman & Brack, 2025, p. 430; See Coman in this handbook) that place Italy among the countries experiencing “destructive dissensus” with respect to liberal democracy. This conclusion depends on the evaluation of two relevant indicators: the object of the dissent (principles themselves or their concrete practice) and the degree of homogeneity or heterogeneity between the goals of political actors. In short, the electoral success of a far-right party such as Fratelli d’Italia (FdI, Brothers of Italy), its leadership in the current government, and its proposals for incisive constitutional reforms (including reforms of the balance between the executive branch and Parliament) are all seen as decisive elements in placing Italy in the most problematic category of the typology proposed in the study. In this chapter, we will elaborate further on the structural characteristics of the Italian system, its constitutional rules, and its historical evolution in order to test this classification. Our aim is to recall that the management of radical dissent is likely inherent to the Italian institutional and political system, considering how it was established after World War II and how it coped with the complexity of the country’s “extreme and polarised pluralism” (Sartori, 1976). These considerations will help us to calibrate the application of Coman and Brack’s analysis to Italy and to place the current status of Italian liberal democracy within the theoretical framework of dissensus. Moreover, we argue that, in the last few years, an evolution in the quality of dissensus has taken place in the Italian constitutional system. During the first 40 years of constitutional democracy (from 1948 onward), the main lines of division were rooted in foreign policy and, domestically, in the exclusion of the Italian Communist Party (PCI, then the main force of the left) from government. This was, above all, a form of disruptive political dissensus based on ideological division (which was somewhat softened, over time, by the changing relationship between the PCI and the Soviet Union). However, this ideological polarisation did not extend to other areas—institutional, social, or legal. Today, by contrast, the level of dissensus among political actors appears to have deepened, particularly with respect to certain social issues (such as migration and security), political matters (notably the stance of FdI on anti-fascism), and institutional questions (such as reforms concerning the form of government and the organisation of the judiciary) that ultimately have an impact on the separation of powers and the rule of law.

Caruso, C., Piccirilli, G. (2026). Dissensus over Liberal Democracy in Italy. Cham : Palgrave MacMillan.

Dissensus over Liberal Democracy in Italy

Corrado Caruso
;
2026

Abstract

The aim of this chapter is to investigate the current state of liberal democracy in Italy. The theoretical framework for this analysis has been provided by recent studies (Coman & Brack, 2025, p. 430; See Coman in this handbook) that place Italy among the countries experiencing “destructive dissensus” with respect to liberal democracy. This conclusion depends on the evaluation of two relevant indicators: the object of the dissent (principles themselves or their concrete practice) and the degree of homogeneity or heterogeneity between the goals of political actors. In short, the electoral success of a far-right party such as Fratelli d’Italia (FdI, Brothers of Italy), its leadership in the current government, and its proposals for incisive constitutional reforms (including reforms of the balance between the executive branch and Parliament) are all seen as decisive elements in placing Italy in the most problematic category of the typology proposed in the study. In this chapter, we will elaborate further on the structural characteristics of the Italian system, its constitutional rules, and its historical evolution in order to test this classification. Our aim is to recall that the management of radical dissent is likely inherent to the Italian institutional and political system, considering how it was established after World War II and how it coped with the complexity of the country’s “extreme and polarised pluralism” (Sartori, 1976). These considerations will help us to calibrate the application of Coman and Brack’s analysis to Italy and to place the current status of Italian liberal democracy within the theoretical framework of dissensus. Moreover, we argue that, in the last few years, an evolution in the quality of dissensus has taken place in the Italian constitutional system. During the first 40 years of constitutional democracy (from 1948 onward), the main lines of division were rooted in foreign policy and, domestically, in the exclusion of the Italian Communist Party (PCI, then the main force of the left) from government. This was, above all, a form of disruptive political dissensus based on ideological division (which was somewhat softened, over time, by the changing relationship between the PCI and the Soviet Union). However, this ideological polarisation did not extend to other areas—institutional, social, or legal. Today, by contrast, the level of dissensus among political actors appears to have deepened, particularly with respect to certain social issues (such as migration and security), political matters (notably the stance of FdI on anti-fascism), and institutional questions (such as reforms concerning the form of government and the organisation of the judiciary) that ultimately have an impact on the separation of powers and the rule of law.
2026
The Palgrave Handbook of Dissensus over Liberal Democracy in Europe
833
847
Caruso, C., Piccirilli, G. (2026). Dissensus over Liberal Democracy in Italy. Cham : Palgrave MacMillan.
Caruso, Corrado; Piccirilli, Giovanni
File in questo prodotto:
Eventuali allegati, non sono esposti

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11585/1088470
 Attenzione

Attenzione! I dati visualizzati non sono stati sottoposti a validazione da parte dell'ateneo

Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
  • OpenAlex ND
social impact